Skip navigation

Vick needs Eagles, but they don’t need him

Reid’s move to sign QB not a football decision — it’s a charity move

Timeline
Michael Vick Appears Appears in Court
The Vick dogfighting drama
Take a look at the key dates in the dogfighting case against Michael Vick.

NBCSports.com

ProFootballTalk’s Picks
Carolina Panthers v Dallas Cowboys
Cowboys headed for happy Thanksgiving
Dallas will beat Oakland, while Packers, Giants will also get holiday wins

ProFootballTalk.com

Video: Football from NBC Sports
Washington Redskins v Dallas Cowboys
Getty Images
No more Romo?
Fantasy Fix: Among the topics to face on Thanksgiving week is whether it's time to bench Tony Romo.

Slideshow
Denver Broncos v Washington Redskins
  Sideline support
Check out some of the NFL cheerleaders from across the league.

more photos

OPINION
By Tom E. Curran
NBCSports.com
updated 1:42 a.m. ET Aug. 14, 2009

Image: Tom Curran
Tom E. Curran

E-mail
Clues that Michael Vick might become a Philadelphia Eagle were out there. But the fact he became one Thursday night? Still a shocker.

Why? Two reasons. The first is pretty basic. As recently as Tuesday, people within the organization scoffed at the notion of signing Vick. Laughed about it even being a possibility.

The second reason? The Eagles don’t need Michael Vick. At all.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

Michael Vick is an Eagle because the Eagles believe this is the right thing to do.

This is a charity move orchestrated by Eagles coach Andy Reid. It’s a softhearted, Father Flanagan, “there are no bad boys” decision.

This isn’t going to make the 2009 Philadelphia Eagles appreciably better. It might make them worse. This is a team that had the lead in the NFC Championship last year with three minutes remaining. This is a team that has an enviable situation at quarterback with a veteran Pro Bowler in Donovan McNabb, a decent veteran in A.J. Feeley and a young, developing QB in Kevin Kolb, whom the Eagles thought enough of to spend a second-round pick on.

We all missed the boat. We all presumed that the team hiring Vick would have A) a quarterback situation in some disarray, B) a renegade owner desperate to win and C) a fan base that would either be unmoved by V ick’s presence because the team stunk or they were desperate.

NFL blog
Get latest on Vick from PFT
Profootballtalk.com is hosted by NBCSports.com, giving you the latest greatest NFL rumors.
And none of those elements are in play for the Eagles.

Now, you and I can go round and round on whether Vick deserves such benevolence so quickly. Ultimately, neither of us will be proven right or wrong, no matter which side we take.

But you cannot argue the good intentions of Reid and the Philly brass he swayed to pursue Vick: owner Jeffrey Lurie, president Joe Banner and GM Tom Heckert. They are extending themselves to give Vick a shot at redemption.

It is a humane thing to do for a person like Vick, whose inhuman actions currently define him.

Reid was very up front about the motivating factors for his pushing the team to sign Vick. His sons, Garrett and Britt, were both jailed in November 2007 for drug-related offenses and Reid is full of empathy for Vick.

“I'm a believer that, as long as people go through the right process, they deserve a second chance,” said Reid. “Michael has done that. I've done a tremendous amount of homework on this and followed his progress. He’s got some great people in his corner and he's proven he's on the right track. ... I’ve seen people close to me that have had second chances and taken advantage of those, and it's very important that people give them opportunities to prove that they can change and we’re doing that with Michael.”

Later, Reid said, “I’ve followed Michael Vick’s situation very closely with the things my boys have been through. I’ve lived that and I’ve seen change on my family’s side.”

The football, here, is an afterthought. Reid didn’t even work Vick out to see what kind of shape he’s in.


Sponsored links